Top 10 South Florida Ice Cream Places

When it comes to dessert, my family is basically a traveling sweet tooth troupe. I’m the cookie-dough thief—you’ll never catch me baking a batch of cookies without at least half the dough mysteriously disappearing before the oven even preheats. So naturally my go to ice cream flavor is the classic cookie dough. My kids are loyal to cookies & cream, because apparently plain vanilla is a crime. My husband? He’s a milkshake connoisseur. He’s sampled just about every cake batter flavor out there, and Cold Stone still reigns supreme in his book. We're not partial to ice cream though. Cookies and brownies are high on our sweet treat list as well. Basically, if it’s sweet, we’ll find a way to argue over the last bite. South Florida is no stranger to dessert places. Especially ice cream.

Top 10 Most Popular Ice Cream Places in South Florida

1. Let’s Chill Homemade Ice Cream – Coral Springs

Ranked #2 in the entire U.S. by Yelp for its house-made, preservative-free ice cream. Famous for its vibrant colors, inventive dairy-free flavors, and even boozy ice cream flights—yes, actual rum in your scoop.

2. The Magic Cow – Davie (and a Coral Springs location)

Claimed the #10 spot in the country on Yelp’s Top 100 list. Known for its quirky, Instagram-ready presentation, over 30 rotating flavors—including oddballs like buttered popcorn and green apple—and tons of mix-ins. It’s a creamy, colorful experience.

3. Sloan’s Ice Cream – Boca Raton & West Palm Beach

This carnival-themed spot isn’t just about ice cream—it’s a whole vibe with plush toys, hot-pink interiors, and over-the-top sundaes that scream fun. A South Florida tradition since 1999.

4. Cream – Delray Beach

A local favorite right off Linton—serving up ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt, brownies, and banana bread. Quality is high, and kids love having options.

5. Jaxson’s Ice Cream Parlour – Dania Beach (near Fort Lauderdale)

Since 1956, this nostalgic, family-run parlor has been delivering giant scoops, huge sundaes, shakes, and even ice cream-topped waffles. The old-school charm, penny candy, and retro decor makes it a must-visit.

6. Lily’s Handmade Ice Cream – Delray Beach & North Miami Beach

This family-owned gem has been voted “Best Ice Cream” in South Florida and wins hearts with its artisan flavors and hometown charm.

7. Whip ’n Dip – Coral Gables (Miami)

A local classic since 1985, beloved for its homemade-style ice cream, nostalgic 80’s Miami vibe, and unique flavors like matcha Thai tea, cookies & cream, and smoke-roasted pistachio.

8. Sweet & Sticky – Miami

One of Yelp’s current top-rated ice cream spots in Miami, offering rich flavors and standout reviews from the locals.

9. Azúcar Ice Cream – Little Havana, Miami

A Cuban-inspired dessert haven—flavors include guava-and-cream cheese, caramel flan, and Cuban coffee + Oreos. A true taste of Miami’s Latin heritage.

10. Super Scoops – Treasure Island area (St. Pete / Tampa vicinity)

Highlighted on a statewide “best ice cream spots” roundup—classic vibes, tasty scoops, and a rewarding stop along many Florida routes.

I haven't had the privledge of visiting all of these stores but I have been to Sloan's many times and absolutely love it! Here is why.... The Experience is a visual & flavor wonderland! They have Fantasy-inspired décor with bright pink walls, twinkling chandeliers, moving miniature trains, and magical glass bathroom doors. They have a treat-filled ambiance. The stores brim with freshly baked waffle cones, homemade cookies and brownies, bulk candy bins, candied apples, chocolate truffles, and even fluffy toys.

Sloan’s offers an extensive and ever-evolving list of inventive flavors, including:

• Circus – cotton candy ice cream packed with gummy bears

• Birthday – buttercream‑frosted chocolate and yellow birthday cake pieces

• Cookie Monster – sandwiches and chocolate chip cookies

• Dad’s Milk Chocolate – creamy milk chocolate

• Extraordinary Vanilla – classic yet luxurious vanilla made from top-tier ingredients

Other standouts include Coffee and Doughnuts, Carrot Cake, Elvis’ Favorite, Minnie & Indy’s Fluffy Road, Scout’s Honor, plus vegan flavors like Vegan Coconut Chocolate, Vegan Peanut Butter, and Vegan Strawberry.

Flavors rotate regularly, so it’s always worth checking in advance.

sloansicecream.com